Controversy books

Number of items: 13

Filter items

בחר קטגוריות להצגה
Select a category
Sold
Auction 098
Item 13
"Sefat Emet V'Lashon Zehorit". [Altona], [1752]. First edition

Sefat Emet V’Lashon Zehorit. Work opposing amulets with suspicious connection to the Sabbateans written by Rabbi Yehonatan Eibshitz, authored by Rabbi Yaakov Emden.
Specifications: [24] leaves, 20 cm. Sketches. First edition. Incomplete copy.
Backgound: Especially resolute work written by Rabbi Yaakov Emden against Rabbi Yehonatan Eibshitz. Includes copies of amulets attributed to Rabbi Eibshitz, and Rabbi Yaakov Emden’s proofs that they were written according to Sabbatean beliefs. The second section features letters from rabbis opposing Rabbi Yehonatan Eibshitz. The Luchat HaEidut [Altona, 1756] was printed to refute this work and justify Rabbi Eibshitz, with his preface.This work was at the center of a stormy controversy and many copies were destroyed. Many of the surviving copies are incomplete. Most complete copies have 34 leaves, but there are a few known copies with 4 additional leaves.This copy has 24 leaves. Details of the missing leaves will be provided upon request.
Condition: Fine. Minimal aging stains and worming holes. New half-leather and marbleized paper binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 14
"Adar Chachamim". Odessa, 1868. Preface by Mendele Mocher Seforim

Defense of the Talmud, rebuttal to the libels of the Netivot Olam, by Christian Alexander McCall (London, 1839), by Naftali Hertz Bornstein. Published by S.Y. Abramowitz (Shalom Yaakov Abramowitz = Mendele Mocher Seforim).
Specifications: [7], 59 pages. 20 cm. First edition.
Unique features: Title page in Hebrew and Russian. Preface by Mendele Mocher Seforim with a short review of the books published to refute the Netivot Olam. The book was written by the author, a London resident, soon after the Netivot Olam was published.
Content: Bound with: Sefer HaChozeh by Yaakov Zvi Sobel, Odessa, 1872. Sobel (1831-1913) uses epic poetry to critique the lifestyle of Russian Jewry (refer to Kressel, Lexicon, p. 476).
Condition: Very fine. Simple, blemished binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 15
"Habakuk" with the translation of Rabbi Dovid Deutsch, opposing Mendelssohn's "Biur". Breslau, 1837

Book of Habakuk, translated and elucidated into Yiddish by Rabbi Dovid Deutsch, Av Beit Din of Żary (Silesia).
Specifications: 39 pages. 17 cm. Translation printed on the left page with the elucidation in its margins.
Background: Rabbi Dovid Deutsch (1810-1873) was a disciple of Rabbi Mordechai Bennet and the Chatam Sofer. He battled the Reform his whole life. He published works opposing the Reform conventions in Brunswick and Frankfurt, opposed Geiger, and sharply attacked Rabbi Rativer for allowing an organ in the synagogue. He also reprinted the Chizuk Emunah with his comments. His elucidation on the Book of Habakuk was the first work he published. Though he was not yet thirty years old, it clearly indicates his mastery of Biblical elucidation. [Sources: Chatam Sofer V’Talmidav, p. 105; Maggid newspaper, 25th of Elul, 1873, p. 341]”His primary intention was to provide scholars with a “kosher elucidation” so they would not need Mendelssohn’s works that were banned by the leading Torah scholars of the time.
Condition: Very fine. Simple binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 16
"Keter Kehuna". Odessa, 1868

A polemic against Chassidut and its leaders by Alexander Zederbaum editor of “HaMelitz”.
Specifications: 6, 182 pages. 18 cm. Blue binding cover.
Content: The book goes beyond a polemic, and could be described as a document of enmity against the chassidic movement and its leaders. It compares the chassidic movement to Catholic cults and disparages its leaders and founders. However, within this is an interesting overview of the development of Chassidut in all of its different branches, and about the debate with those who oppose chassidut. In the book, he disparages giving a “pidyon” to righteous people (page 77), and chassidic tales (page 87 onward), expresses opposition to Breslov chassidim who prostrate themselves on Rabbi Nachman’s grave in Uman (page 109), mentions the importance the Chassidim attribute to the printing press in Salvita “excessive holiness is attributed to every book produced by it” (page 139) and mentions the imprisonment of Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (page 110) and his son Rabbi Avraham Yaakov of Sadigora (page 143).
Condition: Very fine, Aging stains. Simple binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 17
"Nogeh HaTzedek-Ohr Noga." The first Reform work in Germany. Dessau, 1818

Responsa for the wise of the nation, because of the opposition to the changes that the Reform leaders wished to institute in the Hamburg synagogue, such as changes in prayers and organ playing in synagogue, cancelling repetition of the chazan and more, by Eliezer Leiberman.
Specifications: 28 pages: [8] leaves [1] 2-52 pages. 19 cm.
Unique features: This is the first work with “revisions” to religion by the first Reformers in Germany. The pages of the book bear over twenty comments in an Ashkenazic hand, refuting the ideas in the book, disproving the weak arguments, showing that the comparisons do not compare, and attacking the exaggerated mistakes.
Content: The first section features responsa from the Leghorn rabbis allowing an organ in the synagogue [on weekdays] and a responsum from Aaron Choriner allowing the use of the organ even on Shabbat! It also includes proofs and other dubious authorizations, all as-if with pure halachic explanations, in addition to a letter from R’ Moshe Kunitzer.
Background: Torah leaders: the Chatam Sofer; Mahara”m Benet; and the Mahar”i of Lissa, author of the Netivot HaMishpat, all wrote strongly against this work and stated that it was heritical. Refer to their letters printed in Eileh Divrei HaBrit (Hamburg, 1819).
Condition: Very fine. Minimal aging stains. Simple binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 18
"Sefer Nitzachon". Amsterdam, 1709. First Jewish Edition

A polemic against Christianity by Rabbi Yom Tov Lipman Muhlhausen. Arranged in the order of the portions of the Torah and books of the Bible. With Teshuvot HaRadak L’Notzrim.
Specifications: 110 leaves, 12 cm.
Unique Features: A historically important book printed as a response to the Christian attacks in the book Tela Ignea Satanae [The Fiery Darts of Satan]. The first edition of the book printed by Jews, without the sections written by Christians against Judaism. As written on the title page: Reprinted to fulfill the desire of those who want to find words to beat and silence those who speak negatively about G-d and His messiah, in a manner that anyone who reads this book will know what to respond.
Condition: Fine. Aging stains. Original parchment binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 19
"Sifrut V'Koach". "Hoda'at Ba'al Din". Frankfurt am Main, 1866

Proofs that the New Testament confirms the 13 Principles of Faith and opposing the Christian faith, by David Don Nasi.
Specifications: 32 pages, 13 cm. Vinograd-Rosenfeld number 84616.
Unique Features: Extremely rare. Published from a manuscript by [Rafael Kirchheim].
Condition: Very fine. Simple binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 20
"Yerushalmi Kadshim". Forgery. 1906-1907

Talmud Yerushalmi Seder Kadshim on Tractates Chulin and Bechorot, with the Cheshek Shlomo commentary by Rabbi Shlomo Yehuda Friedlander.
Specifications: [10] 78: [1] 46 leaves. Section two. 35 cm. Opens with two title pages in red and black, additional title page for Tractate Bechorot.
Background: When the work was first published, it was enthusiastically received in the Jewish world. At first they believed that the Talmud Yerushalmi on this seder had previously been lost, and now they merited to rediscover the wisdom within it. However, they quickly discovered that Friedlander had forged the entire work! The episode stirred a giant polemic and many booklets and placards were printed in favor and opposing the work. With absolute impunity, Friedlander cast his net and caused leading Torah personalities to fall; he succeeded in receiving passionate approbations, printed at the beginning of this work. A few proofs regarding the forgery was printed in the “Kedem” journal, which is also presented in this catalogue.
Condition: Very fine. Minimal reinforcements to the first and last leaves.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 21
Die Orgel in der Synagoge, eine Erörterung, by David Deutsch, Breslau, 1863

A polemic book which discusses putting a harp in synagogues.
Specifications: VII, 83 pages. 12×19 cm.
Unique Features: The book is written in German, but halachic expressions, names of halachic books, names of instruments and quotes of halachic sources are in Hebrew.
Background: Due to aesthetic and ritual changes instituted by the leaders of the Reform movement, beginning in the second decade of the 19th century, there were certain communities who made changes to the structure of the synagogue and to its activities. Among other things, they changed the prayer liturgy, changed the location of the bimah and the seating arrangements in the synagogue, instituted weekly sermons in the local language and choral singing during the prayers. Reform Jews also began to bring a harp into the synagogue to provide musical accompaniment to the prayers. This all caused stormy polemics among the supporters and opponents of the Reform movement.
Condition: Very fine. Aging stains. Cardboard binding.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Auction 098
Item 22
Kadmot Sefer HaZohar, [Konigsberg 1855], Ma'amarim Nichbadim, Warsaw 1851, by Rabbi David Luria - Radal. First Edition

a. Kadmot Sefer HaZohar. A long article replete with astounding knowledge to prove the origins and true sources of the book of the Zohar by Rabbi David Luria (the Radal) of Byhov.
Specifications: [2], 36; 8 leaves. 20 cm.
Unique Features: The final booklet, “Kina L’David” – is a eulogy on the Radal by Rabbi Yechiel Heller, author of Amudei Esh.
Condition: Very fine.
b. Ma’amarim Yekarim V’Dvarim Nechbadim. Introductions to Pirkei D’Rabbi Eliezer written by Radal as an introduction to his commentary on Pirkei D’Rabbi Eliezer.
1. Shem Ha’Echad Eliezer – praises of Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus and his character traits based on the Talmudic literature.
2. Emek Bracha regarding the Talmudic discussion that Rabbi Eliezer is “shamuti”.
3. Beit Tzadik – his history and family history.
Specifications: [1], 44 leaves. 16 cm.
Condition: Very fine.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 23
Polemic. "Shu"t Mecholat HaMachanayim". Pressburg, 1859. First edition

Unique work opposing changes to prayers and synagogue arrangements, primarily regarding holding wedding ceremonies in the synagogue and moving the location of the bimah. Authored by Rabbi Yisrael Dovid Margoliot Yaffe, Av Beit Din of Pezinok, disciple of the Chatam Sofer.
Specifications: [1], 80, [3] leaves. 19 cm. The last pagination includes a list of subscribers and catalogue of a book merchant in Pressburg. First edition.
Unique features: Includes a lengthy article with interesting proofs from numerology opposing the square hats worn by the Reformers.
Condition: Very fine. Marginal reinforcements to solitary leaves. Minimal aging stains.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

Auction 098
Item 24
Polemic. "Shu"t Parshat Mordechai". Brunn, 1790. First edition

Responsa by Rabbi Halberstat, Av Beit Din of Dusseldorf, with responses from the sages of the generation.
Specifications: [6], 2-104 leaves. 21 cm. First edition.
Unique features: Approbation of Rabbi Yaakov Yehoshua HaLevi Horowitz, Av Beit Din of Trebitsch, son of Rabbi Shmelke of Nikolsburg. This book is very rare, as the rabbis of Frankfurt of the time ordered it destroyed because it contained a response from the Pnei Yehoshua regarding creating a passage for kohanim that did not take into account impurity from the deceased. The Frankfurt rabbis strongly opposed this heter. The author of Nachal Eshkol writes in his Brit Avraham (Frankfurt A.M., 1870): “Come and I will show you a work titled Shu”t Maamar Mordechai by the Gaon…of Brunn, 1789, which was printed…but it was not found for years in the city and its environs, I believe that the sages of Frankfurt destroyed them, since they found the responsum, from the author of the Pnei Yehoshua, different from what it written in the index: “the Maharich allows making a passage for kohanim without worrying about what’s under the ground and the beit din of Frankfurt did not agree with this.”
Condition: Very fine-excellent. Not bound.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Auction 098
Item 25
Polemic. The "Cleves Get". "Ohr Yisrael". Cleves, [1770], complete copy with rare simanim. First edition.

Responsa, primarily related to the “Cleves Get”, by Rabbi Yisrael Lipshitz, Av Beit Din of Cleves.
Specifications: 66, 69-120 leaves. 20 cm. First edition.
Unique features: Rare. This copy includes simanim 34-36 that were omitted from most copies because of the sharp proclamation issued in Cleves against the rabbis of Frankfurt. Refer to: Shlomo Tal, HaGet Mi’Kleva, Sinai, volume 24 (1949), p. 214.
Background: Rabbi Yisrael Lipshitz, Rabbi of Cleves in northwestern Germany, found himself at the center of one of the largest halachic polemics. The question revolved around a groom that fled during his sheva berachot with unusual claims. A few days later, he fled again until he was caught in Cleves, where Rabbi Yisrael arranged a get, per the groom’s request. The rabbis of Frankfurt objected to the validity of the divorce, claiming that the groom was crazy. This led to a large disagreement, most of the leading rabbis sided with the opinion of the rabbi of Cleves. The first 33 responses in this work related to this episode. The Ohr HaYashar also deals with this issue.
Condition: Very fine. Reinforcements and light blemishes to the title page and last leaf.

Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".
Error: the field format must contains "%s" or "%1$s".

The price includes a buyer's commission

התחל להקליד ע"מ לקבל תוצאות רלוונטיות

Question about item

Polemic. “Shu”t Mecholat HaMachanayim”. Pressburg, 1859. First edition

Start typing p to get relevant results

Auction house conditions

A GUIDE TO THE PARTICIPANTS IN THE EXHIBITION AND PUBLIC AUCTION REGULATUON AND PROCEDURES
 Winner’s Auction LTD (the company) – is hereby holding an exhibition in Judaica, to enable the public to examine these
important items, with the possibility of purchasing them at an auction sale to be held at the conclusion of the exhibition. For the convenience
of the public, we have published a detailed catalogue with photographs and descriptions for each item. Catalouge description are based on
the opinions of our experts. However, the sole responsibility of the buyer to inspect each lot. Please regard the catalogue as your personal
guide to the exhibition and auction. Our staff will be at your assistance throughout the exhibition and auction.
Administration of the auction and conditions of Auction:
The auction itself will be directed by an experienced auctioneer according to the standards and regulations of auction houses. We request
visitors and participants to familiarize themselves with the regulations and current conditions. We recommend that people unfamiliar with
these regulations ask our staff at the exhibition for the information they deem necessary.
* Participation in the public auction and receipt of a “participant’s number” are tantamount to the confirming and agreeing that the
recipient of the number is familiar with the regulations, procedures, and conditions of our exhibitions and public sales. Any problems
arising during the auction sale or afterwards as a result of a purchase will be resolved by the purchaser and the management of the company
in according with accepted practice.
* Since the company is merely the organizer and administrator of the exhibition and auction, and is not the owner of the items themselves,
it is hereby agreed and stipulated that in no case will the Company be responsible to the purchasers after the transfer of the payment to the
seller- owners. Thus, in case the payment received from a purchaser has already been transferred to the owner, and even if the complaint
or claim made by the purchaser is justified, and we make every effort to have his money retuned to him by the owner, we shall be under
no obligations to do so, and shall not engage in any legal proceedings after it has been handed over to the owner, though we shall agree
to provide the purchaser with suitable documentations on our part to enable him to engage in such legal proceedings against the owner.
* Upon receipt of the “participant’s number”, in person or via telephone, the potential buyer agrees and obligates himself not to prosecute
us or place a lawsuit against us in the event of damage caused or error in the catalogue description. Any complaints or claim after transfer
of the money to the seller, are only valid against the seller himself.
Prices and Estimates:
Participations in the auction is expressed: (a) by the personal presence of the purchaser in the hall; (b) by the presence of his representative;
(c) by means of written or telephoned bids empowering the management of the company to purchase various items for the person ordering
them (d) Via the Internet.
* The presence of the purchaser’s representative obliges him to make good his purchases, with whatever this entails. The company shall
not agree to obligate his sender or to free the representative of any obligation, even though the representative may fill his sender’s name
explicitly in our forms.
* If we receive a telephone or written order for a certain item, we shall strive to act in the interest of the person giving the order, just as if
he himself was in the hall. We, however, are under no obligation to obtain the item for him.
* We are under no obligation to accept any bid, including the highest bid, even though the purchaser or his representative is personally
present in the hall and participating in the auction.
* The auction itself is administered by announcing numbers in US$, though the actual payment may be made in either Shekalim in
accordance with the average rate of exchange which will be announced at the auction hall or at the day of the payment (The highest) or in USD.
* A 24% commission charge is added to all payment made by purchasers up to $500,000. 20% is added up to $501,000. A Vat ia added only on this comission charges. This percentage is an integral part of the bid accepted by the auctioneer during
the auction, and all obligations, etc, apply also to this percentage
* A foreign resident will be exempt from VAT only if the item purchased is shipped outside of the country by the company without its
guarantee and subject to receipt of an export entry from the custom authorities. The purchaser will cover all related expenses.
* Bank and personal checks are accepted tentatively, until they are honored by the bank.
* Payment by cash, checks or transfers within the country will be accepted without further charge. Foreign checks, credit cards (from
Israel) will be charged an additional 1.5%. bank transfers from foreign countries will be charged an additional 1.5% min. $30. Credit card
payments from foreign countries will be charged an additional 3%.
* Each item is accompanied by an estimate value made by our experts. There is no guarantee that the item will not be sold for a lower
estimate nor that the actual price of the item will not be much higher than the highest estimate value. This paragraph does not detract from
our consistent defense of the minimum price determined by the owner of the item.
Additional information and conditions:
* The purchaser or his representative will claim the purchased item as soon as possible. We request that he appear within seven days to
make the payment and collect the acquisition: under no circumstances is this to take place after 14 days from actual date of auction. After 14 days storage charges may be charged of $5.00 per lot per day. The purchaser himself is solely responsible for the dispatch of items to his home, in any way that he deems fit. The purchaser is responsible for the costs involved in such dispatch. Optional shipping insurance is available.
* The purchased item will not leave the company’s premises until payment is made.
* If payment is not received within 14 days of the auction, Winners reserves the right to cancel the sale unilaterally, without foregoing
their claim for commission.
* ATTENTION OWNERS: The company is not responsible for the actual carrying- out of payments undertaken by the purchasers during
the auction. In the event that obligations by the purchaser are not honored, we shall support the former owner of the item is taking steps
to obtain the payment owing him, but we shall not engage in legal procedures against purchasers. We shall proceed in all ways we find
suitable, but we are under no obligations to do so.
* Purchasers and sellers agree to be considered legal parties in every way in case we exercise the rights we are hereby granted to engage in
legal proceedings, or any other accepted steps against a party who does not honor its obligations.
* The Hebrew text of the catalogue is the correct version, and overrides any addition, omission or change in the English translation